Forum > Warcraft III
uk SK|Malystryx
53,979 XP

Malystryx


Elite
WCG 2004 or 2008?

Which would you rate higher? Take into account, coverage, playoff matches and participants.

For me 2008 wins simply because quality of the quarter/semi/ and final but perhaps its different if you watching from a distance?

What are your views?

Posted: 2008-11-09 15:22:42

Comments

« Previous1Next »
uk SK|Zechs
31,316 XP

Zechs


Super Old School
Coverage this year was a disgrace. Worse than ESWC Masters of Paris. Can't even compare 08 with 04 because i've seen 5 games out of the whole tournament.
se LittleD
19,807 XP

LittleD


Newbie
This year's WCG was a mix of Bad/repaired/Good/suprising/rememberable things. But if we just get the replays as soon as possible it think I might forgive them for the bad things.
at e-spider
21,377 XP

e-spider


Pro
coverage was bad; just the one at SK was really good, so much vids etc...
overall i rate 2004 a bit higher!
se endarspire
16,391 XP

endarspire


Elite
Madfrog vs Crimson. Thats all I have to say!
cf Betman
1 XP

no image


Newbie
2004 because they streamed more games!!
nz Contrail1
16,324 XP

no image


Pro
I think 2004 was more influenctial as it launched him onto the world stage.

From a gaming perspective this one was far more impressive.
es Rhaeide
10,777 XP

Rhaeide


Normal
King.Crimson FTW xD
uk SK|Zechs
31,316 XP

Zechs


Super Old School
@Zechs
Just to be clear, btw, WCG's own coverage was the problem. SK's was almost as good as if i'd been there ;)
fr eports_warwolf
23,881 XP

eports_warwolf


Pro
Grubby himself said in an interview 2008 was better because in 2004 he wasn't pro, he didn't consider he deserved the victory at all. After this, he improved himself, the game changed.

In WCG2008, he really wanted the win, and this was the tournament he worked the most for. + He didnt want to disappoint his fan one more time + he wanted to show he deserves to be a MYM player + his family was here + he wanted to bring back people trust etc.

I can give you a link for Grubby's interview (Moon got interviewed too) but it's in french... http://www.esportsfrance.com/reportage/actualites/1088/
at e-spider
21,377 XP

e-spider


Pro
@eports_warwolf
which makes it ueseless for like 98% here :D
btw didnt esportfrance used to translate the interviews in english?
fr eports_warwolf
23,881 XP

eports_warwolf


Pro
@eports_warwolf
e-spider, only very importants ones (and if one of the translator is available to do it). This one is a part of the coverage we've made there, not a prepared itw etc.
at e-spider
21,377 XP

e-spider


Pro
@eports_warwolf
damn, this is like one of the most important ones, wake that f***** translator up or get him away from his beer and make him work work! :D
bg Numb
17,063 XP

Numb


Elite
@Zechs
Can you tell me why do you think so?
Because i watched CS, WC and SC and i like it
fr eports_warwolf
23,881 XP

eports_warwolf


Pro
@eports_warwolf
e-spider, Actually, just noticed we've just translated the press conference :D
So, whole interviews here http://www.mymym.com/en/coverage/536/66.html
bg Numb
17,063 XP

Numb


Elite
@eports_warwolf
So damn right! If the interview with the WCG champion and the runner-up is not important, than what?
de FunPlayer
15,431 XP

FunPlayer


Pro
It's basically Grubby saying he never worked harder for a title, it's his most important one because of his family and fans cheering form him. After beating Infi and later Tod he felt like he could win it. WCG organisation is great. He doesn't waste a thought on SC2 after winning the biggest Wc3 title for now. And of course when playing against Moon every little mistake is fatal, the pressure nwas enormous.

Moon says he's sad, but will come back next year to finally win WCG. He made some mistakes that Grubby took advantage of, being the good player that he is. He said he's proud to have Grubby in his team but also that preparing strategies vs a teammate you practice against so often is difficult. Plus he had a hard time sleeping the night before that because he was anxious.
de FunPlayer
15,431 XP

FunPlayer


Pro
@FunPlayer
Okay, it's just a transcript from the aftergame interview which can be watched in English here:

http://www.mymym.com/en/coverage/536/66.html

(if Sk doesn't delete it)
fr eports_warwolf
23,881 XP

eports_warwolf


Pro
@FunPlayer
i have already said that, 1h30 ago :x
de FunPlayer
15,431 XP

FunPlayer


Pro
@FunPlayer
wow I'm feeling useless now :D
se Brack
16,283 XP

Brack


Newbie
unable to pick.

Grubby vs Zacard was a epic game for real with both players doing diffrent stuff etc etc at that time.

Moon and Grubby 08 both players in a very very good shape. i mean thats just awesome now give replays :D
nz Sirz
10,445 XP

Sirz


Normal
i still liked 2007 inactive creo> sky ;)
ro cosminich
25,907 XP

cosminich


Pro
WCG2008 is my fav because it was a damn show at Counter-Strike and the Fifa competition won by a romanian.
bg hostilepulse
24,636 XP

hostilepulse


Normal
@Sirz
actually Creo wasnt inactive "completely", he said that he goes inactive after WCG
no ttguy
5,585 XP

no image


Pro
@Sirz
Actually he told me he quit playing completely, but he'd participate WCG since he already earned his slot and would take it as a free trip and a chance to see his friends for probably the last time.
no ttguy
5,585 XP

no image


Pro
@Sirz
Actually that comment was for hostilepulse, sup with this forum?
se LittleD
19,807 XP

LittleD


Newbie
@ttguy
When you reply to someone who have already replied to someone your reply will go to the one who the one you were supposed to reply to replied to. (lol that sounded weird, hehe)
So better just to manually write "@name"
Ps: They should really change this.
fr ip0d
10,302 XP

ip0d


Pro
i like the final 2008 Grubby vs Moon was awesome !
fr Toxiii
4,594 XP

no image


Newbie
@LittleD
ps: didnt understand anything
maybe you should go to the doctor
se LittleD
19,807 XP

LittleD


Newbie
@LittleD
Ever considered yourself to visit him? Could cheer you up a bit I think.
Edit: Lol made the same mistake >.>
se vinworvi
596 XP

no image


Pro
Anyone know when final replay is going to be up?
kr PhurreLL
11,616 XP

PhurreLL


Newbie
i'd say 2004, it was more exiciting back then than watching it now.
cl Symphony-rLz
13,187 XP

Symphony-rLz


Elite
i think this one was more exiciting..

just love the Final..
ca endem
11,240 XP

endem


Pro
2k8 was more exiciting. The final was awsome
fi Angina
10,151 XP

Angina


Normal
2k4 was pretty damn exciting, pretty much validation to both Zacard and Grubby for title of best orc player in the world (at the time it was heavily debated) and grubby proved to come out on top with an impressive series of games.

This one wasn't exciting besides the fact that grubby was facing moon in the finals. I think if they ran a bo5 with moon , he woulda lost. But grats to grubby nevertheless, don't get me wrong, I wuv him still and I think he's top 5.
se LittleD
19,807 XP

LittleD


Newbie
Just so everyone knows. The prefix "k" which is oftenly used around the internet stands for "kilo" and means thousand or 1000. So when someone says 2k8 you mathematicly say 20008. To be fully correct it should be 2,008 k which just seems awefully weird. So I don't even know why I brought this up :S
/Suicide
fr MuShu76
8,085 XP

MuShu76


Newbie
2006kqdsfkdsjfd
fr Toxiii
4,594 XP

no image


Newbie
are u just plain stupid or ure trying to get the most shitty points of this forum(WoW included)?
2k8 = 2 thousands 8
which means 2008 in english language
go back to school.
se LittleD
19,807 XP

LittleD


Newbie
Plain stupid ofc, what did u expect? I'm at the Sk-Forums !
de FunPlayer
15,431 XP

FunPlayer


Pro
@LittleD
you probably also ask yourself why progamers are one-three-three-seven, right?
se LittleD
19,807 XP

LittleD


Newbie
You cannot imagine...
ro nihatcoys-
17,082 XP

nihatcoys-


Pro
from the winner's perspective , 2008 must be better , because Grubby was under a lot of fire going in the tournament

besides , the last 2 final games were epic , i lol'd so hard at his BM surviving with 1hp
rs AcaF
11,624 XP

AcaF


Newbie
it was 2 hp :)
no TargA_
20,284 XP

TargA_


Pro
aca touched grubby
bg wind_-
21,006 XP

wind_-


Normal
This year's WCG was a Good suprising end :)